Intensities in Ten Suburbs

Just another weblog

The IITS 2007 Pop Culture Hall of Fame Nominees: Music

Posted by Andrew Unterberger on December 11, 2007

2007, let me holla at you, you so hot hot hot hot

Ah, December–easily the most magical time of the year. Not for all those boring religious and sentimental reasons, and not because of all that snow either (snow being easily the most overrated form of condensation). For a true pop culture buff, December means but one thing–YEAR IN MOTHERFUCKING REVIEW. That’s right, with 11 of 2007’s months officially over and done with, it’s time to start the demanding but infinitely rewarding practice of separating the year’s classics from the clunkers, the epoch-makers from the airspace-wasters, the immortal from the ephemeral. Can’t you feel the electricity in the air?

If not, then it’s time to start. All this week on Intensities and Ten Suburbs, we’ll be looking at the nominees for that most prestigious of year-end distinctions: entry into the IITS Pop Culture Hall of Fame. Long after memories of Big Shots, Hurricane Chris and Tyler Perry’s Why Did I Get Married? fade into the ether, these giants will endure in the public consciousness, towering over all to follow. Over the next five days, we’ll be looking at the music, movies, television, commercials and miscellany that has defined 2007 in popular culture–ten items each, which will ultimately be pared down to the five each, which will go on to live forever in the hallowed annals of Intensites in Ten Suburbs’ trophy room.

This, dear readers, is where you (hopefully) come in. I’d like to have the entries into our hall of fame be decided by you. So at the end of each day, I want you all to write-in your votes of the nominees mentioned. You can vote for up to five, as well as an optional write-in vote that can get honorable mention if I find it a particularly egregious miss on my part. You can post your vote in the comments box, or e-mail it to me at If you don’t want to vote every day, you can wait until the end of the week and submit one complete ballot.


That said, I have learned to be realistic in terms of reader response, and if I don’t receive enough votes, I’ll simply pick the inductees myself. But that won’t be as much fun, now, will it? So please, don’t force me to have to do so.

Now, about the nominees: as should be no surprise to anyone reading this blog, this will not simply be a listing of my favorite songs, albums, movies, TV shows, commercials and current events–you can find best of lists just about anywhere this time of year, and I’ll not be adding to them, not here anyway. Rather, these nominees are culled from the moments that I felt most defined the pop culture landscape in 2007. Consequently, such future-classic songs like The National’s “Mistaken for Strangers” and LCD Soundsystem’s “All My Friends” are not represented, nor are movies like Hot Fuzz or The King of Kong, TV shows like The Wire or Friday Night Lights, or commercials…well, all right, the commercials are probably mostly just gonna be listings of my favorites (there are not yet, to my knowledge, such a thing as indie commercials). But you get the idea.

So first up are the music nominees. Remember, vote for up to five (only voting one or two is OK), with one optional write-in, either in the comments box or at Let’s set a standard for what is hopefully many induction ceremonies to come.


Avril Lavigne Unwittingly Introduces An Obscure Power Pop Act to a New Generation

Choosing just one “Girlfriend”-related moment to put up for the Pop Culture hall of fame is an impossibility. After all, this is the song that was recorded in eight different languages (including the infamous Mandarin version), saw Avril fighting over a guy with her own nerdy doppleganger in the video, and of course featured the best call-and-response hook (and maybe just the best chorus hook period) of the year. But just as good as any was the lawsuit levied against Ms. Lavigne by forgotten 70s power-poppers Rubinoos on the claims that the song was a rip-off of their “I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend“–a claim which might have carried more weight had that song not been a rip-off itself of The Rolling Stones’ “Get Off of My Cloud”. C’mon guys, don’t you know by now? When it comes to music royalty suits, it always comes back to Mick and Keith.

Akon and T-Pain Buy a Time Share in the Top 40

Let’s do a run-down of the Senegalese Sensation and the Robo-R&Ber’s ’07 rap sheet, shall we?

Akon: “Don’t Matter” (#1), Gwen Stefani’s “The Sweet Escape” (#2), Bone Thugz n Harmony’s “I Tried” (#6), “Sorry, Blame it On Me” (#7), Plies’ “Hypnotized” (#24), DJ Khaled’s “We Takin’ Over” (#28), Wyclef Jean’s “The Sweetest Girl” (#32 and rising), and two mega-hits from ’06 still lingering on the charts in the beginning of ’07 (“Smack That” and “I Wanna Love You”)

T-Pain: “Buy U a Drank” (#1), Chris Brown’s “Kiss Kiss” (#1), Flo Rida’s “Low” (#4), Baby Bash’s “Cyclone” (#7), Kanye West’s “Good Life” (#7), Plies’ “Shawty” (#9), R. Kelly’s “I’m a Flirt” (#12), DJ Khaled’s “I’m So Hood” (#19), Bow Wow’s “Outta My System” (#22), “Baby Don’t Go” (#23)

Both: “Bartender” (#5)

And this isn’t even mentioning Akon’s on-stage underage dry hump or long distance fan toss.

Um-buh-reh-lla, ella, ella, ay ay

If you could sum up 2007 pop music in one grammatically inaccurate word, it’d have to be this one. Rihanna rode her irresistible mispronunciation to her second chart-topper, the Best Video award at the VMAs, the unofficial jam of the summer, and the collective ire of more Elementary School english teachers that had been raised by a pop culture item since those “The Birds is coming!” ads in the early 60s. And chart geeks will of course rejoice at the obscure trivia fact that “Umbrella” now makes Jay-Z the only artist in Billboard history to be featured on three different artists’ #1 hits, without ever getting one of his own. Take that, (Ex-)Murda Ma$e!

Soulja Boy Teaches a Grateful Nation How to Crank Dat Soulja Boy

The song and video was inescapable enough, and a more oppressively hypnotic single in recent years I can not recall. But really, when was the last time our country got swept up by a dance craze like this? I mean yeah, “The Cha Cha Slide,” but that was more of a gradual permeation than a genuine sweep, and the “Lean Back” is disqualified on the grounds that I believe you need at least two steps to qualify as a dance craze. Hell, not even Los Del Rio actually released an instructional video for the “Maccarena”. I’ve still yet to hear a proper explanation as to what “Cranking that Roosevelt” entails, however. Do you need a wheelchair for it?

Rock Puts on Its Boogie Shoes

For a while there, it was like 1979 all over again. Seems like almost every band was going disco this year, whether it was designed to revive their lagging careers (Finger Eleven’s “Paralyzer,” Good Charlotte’s “Dance Floor Anthem”), bump their already taking-off careers to the next level (Maroon 5’s “Makes Me Wonder,” Fall Out Boy’s “This Ain’t a Scene, It’s an Arms Race”) or get that ever-elusive first radio hit (Say Anything’s “Wow, I Can Get Sexual Too,” the failure of which to break into the mainstream continues to perplex me somewhat). Fans might’ve cried bloody murder at these crossover attempts the first time around, but luckily, no one really cares about rock any more these days, so we were able to enjoy these radio-ready delectables in a mostly judgement-free environment.

Mims Breaks Down Hotness for the Lay Man

In a rare rap representation of the Reflexive Property of Equality (no, thank you, Mrs. Machnichi!), Mims explains the root cause of his hotness, and your notness: “I’m hot ‘coz I’m fly / You ain’t ‘coz you not.” In most other years, this chorus would mark a nadir of sorts for hip-hop lyricism, but as it turns out, 2007 was just getting going. Nonetheless, the song did display a higher musical IQ than most other rap hits this year (“Shook Ones, Pt. 2”!!!), and it did have a certain self-explanatory charm to it. I still can’t make out 95% of the chorus to “Crank That Soulja Boy,” but there really isn’t any way that “This is Why I’m Hot” could be too much clearer.

Alanis Morissette Puts a Different Spin on Things

Yeah, I did the eye-roll thing when I first heard about this. Forgive me, but I figured Alanis Morissette doing “My Humps” would pack about as much appeal as one of Tori Amos’s SHOCKING covers of Slayer or Eminem or something. But oh, was I proven wrong, as not only did Alanis’s novelty cover become one of the viral video smashes of the calendar year, but it actually didn’t suck much at all. Really, this is because the song sounds less like a parody of “My Humps” (truly one of the most readily-parodiable songs of all-time) than it does a parody of Alanis herself–listen to the bitterness she seethes with as she asks “what you gonna do with alllll that juuuunkkkk, all that juunk IIIN-SAAYYYIIIDE YOUR TRUNK??!?” and flash back to your uncomfortable memories of that annoying girl at school doing a performance of “You Oughta Know” at your 8th grade talent show or something. But then again, here Alanis is, a whole 12 years after Jagged Little Pill, on a list of the elite pop culture moments of the year. So I suppose the last laugh is truly hers.

Amy Winehouse Goes to Rehab

The punniest and least-surprisng music celebrity headline since C-Murder (OK, loose definition of celebrity) was arrested for murder, Amy Winehouse was struck with some exceptionally bad (or good, depending) timing when she entered rehab just weeks after her single of the same name peaked in the top ten in the US. Really though, it was sort of unreal that Winehouse got there in the first place–chalk it up to that once a year phenomenon (’04: “Float On,” ’05: “Feel Good Inc.,” ’06: “Crazy”) of a single eclipsing presumed commercial boundaries just because it really was that good. Let’s just hope she lives to enjoy her success for at least a little while.

MTV Takes Issue With the Chorus to Sean Kingston’s “Beautiful Girls”

Now, I’m not generally for Radio Edits replacing objectionable words in songs with ones that are less so–unless, of course it’s taken to comically ridiculous levels, as in the classic case of Weezer’s “We Are All In Love.” But in any event, it’s generally preferrable to edits that just blur out the words entirely, especially in the case of Sean Kingston’s summer smash, wher those objectionable words made up about half of the chorus. So instead of getting one of the great singalong choruses of 2007 when you see the video on MTV, you get “You’re way too beaaauuuuutiful girl / That’s why it’ll never work / You’ll leave me …. / …. / when you say that it’s ooooverrrr.” Also, if MTV really dislikes even the most casual “suicidal” mentions, then they have the extreme over-exposure of a certain early-90s grunge video to answer for.

It’s Britney, Bitch

2007…it probably didn’t quite turn out the way Britney Spears had hoped. Rehab, a high-profile divorce, a freak gardening accident that left her the least sexy bald woman since Marcia Cross in Melrose Place, a titanically disastrous interview in OK! Magazine, and, of course, a total bomb of a performance at the 2007 VMAs, where even lip synching properly seems too much for the drugged out and/or very, very sleep-deprived Spears to handle. However, she managed to hang on to some semblance of a career, thanks to those three sweetest words in the English Language, which provided the ringtone-ready hook to an otherwise entirely lifeless comeback single. And if the “Gimme More” video showed that Britney has little desire to turn around her wayward ways, well, at least we got one of the decade’s great catchphrases out of it.

Honorable Mention:

Timbaland Moves to the Left of the “F/” Symbol
Colbie Calliat and Taylor Swift: Guitar is the New Piano
Gym Class Heroes sampling Supertramp and Jermaine Stewart
R. Kelly’s Videos for “Real Talk,” “Same Girl” and “Trapped in the Closet (Parts 13-22)”


30 Responses to “The IITS 2007 Pop Culture Hall of Fame Nominees: Music”

  1. T-t-t-t-t-t-t-t-totally dude!
    Soulja Boy

  2. Jason L said

    Here’s how I would rank ’em:

    1. Akon and T-Pain becoming unstoppable
    2. Britney mania
    3. You can combine MIMS and Souljah Boy, since they caused the further numbskullification of commercial rap
    4. Write-in: Huuuuge year for reunions and subsequent tours/festival appearances (Genesis, The Police, Rage, Jesus and Mary Chain, Van Halen, etc.)
    5. Amy Winehouse becoming popular despite vehement action to prevent this
    5. Another write-in: indie bands crossing over to find Billboard success (Shins, Arcade Fire, Modest Mouse, Spoon)

    Thank you for starting the year-end lists, I love them so so much..

  3. Eric said

    Soulja Boy

    Everybody else, wait till’ next year.

  4. Richard said

    1. Rihanna
    2. Britney
    3. Avril
    4. Amy
    5. Alanis

  5. my kinetic android said

    Rihanna – who I like to blame for causing the floods in England this summer, no matter how implausible it seems.

    Amy Winehouse – The female version of Pete Doherty. I’m waiting for her to die too. “Rehab” is not that good either, so there.

    Britney bitch – A breakdown! OMG!

    T-Pain & Akon – They ought to write a book on getting into every chart hit this year.

    Mims – Because… he’s… hot?

  6. Bouncy said

    1.) Akon/T-Pain – “Bartender”
    2.) Soulja Boy
    3.) “Girlfriend”
    4.) Kells + Usher
    5.) “Rehab”

  7. Brent said

    1) Rock Goes Disco
    2) “Girlfriend”
    3) “Umbrella”
    4) Colbie Caillat and especially Taylor Swift
    5) The T-Pain/Akon takeover

  8. Al said

    1. Soulja Boy (transcended music and became a punchline for every comedic hack out there)

    2. Britney (Followed 24-7, propped up every prospering tabloid show and site out there. Only thing holding her back from top spot is that she did a lot in 2006 as well)

    3. Umbrella-ella-ella-ella (great song, enjoyed by moppets and hipster douche bags alike)

    4. Winehouse (I didn’t care about her story, but she is everywhere now. Perhaps the most disgusting celebrity of all-time?)

    5. Akon (and T-Pain) (I would’ve probably placed Akon higher all by himself, but you forced me to group him with T-Pain who I didn’t really follow. There was a time in Spring when Akon owned the airwaves)

  9. Josh Love said

    hmm, these are all entertaining, but I think only Soulja Boy and Britney are truly Hall-worthy. after all, it’s not the hall of very goodOMGROFFLEZ.

  10. Josh Love said

    oh, and “Chocolate Rain” better show up somewhere. that’s a first-ballot shoo-in.

  11. Anton said

    1 – Rihanna, for a classic song.
    2 – Britney, for relapse into white-trashdom of glorious proportion. Her tale will be as infamous as any before her.
    3 – MIMS, for a song that will likely (and hopefully) become as ubiquitous in commercials and VH1 themes as Cake songs.
    4 – GYM Class Heroes, I can’t believe they’re only in the honorable mention.
    5 – Akon and T-Pain will definitely be remembered for a long time by future generations in that way that future generations tend to remember someone’s name and vaguely the reason why they were famous, but not much else.

    I guess it’s cool that Rock Went Disco a little more this year, but I liked the whole hipster-rockers-learn-to-dance phenomenon the first time it happened in 2003.

  12. Dan said

    Soulja Boy
    This Is Why I’m Hot
    R. Kelly

  13. Greg Fanoe said

    1. Britney – (transcends music)
    2. T-t-t-totally dude (excellent novelty hit in an era devoid of good novelty hits)
    3. Avril
    4. Soulja Boy
    5. Colbie & Taylor

  14. INotI said

    Man, I knew I was out of touch with what’s popular these days, but I didn’t realize how bad it really is. I only know what you’re talking about for maybe two of these.

  15. Rob James said

    I vote for all the chick stuff.

  16. Rob James said

    I vote for all the chick stuff.

  17. David said

    1. Avril
    2. Hannah Montana Ticket Brouhaha
    3. Soulja Boy

  18. Ken said


  19. Haley said

    1. Britney ( for the sheer fact that I cannot escape her disasterous life anywhere I turn )
    2. T-Pain and Akon ( they cannot be stopped )
    3. Rihanna
    4. Soulja Boy ( I don’t see MIMS going on Ellen to teach people his ‘dance’ moves )
    5. Avril Lavigne

  20. Sonja said

    1. Rehab- awesome.
    2. MTV + Sean Kingston
    3. Avril
    4. Alanis
    5. Umbrella

  21. 1. Brit-Brit
    2. Amy
    3. Rihanna
    4. Avril
    5. Alanis

  22. jonathan said

    1. Crank dat Various Things.
    2. T-Pain/Akon’s robot rampage.
    3. Umb-uh-rella-ella-ella-ella-eh-eh-eh-eh-zombie-eee-eee-eee!
    4. It’s Britney, bitch!
    5. “Yo Ush,” “What up, Kells?”

    Write-in: 50 v Kanye

  23. David said

    1. It’s Britney Bitch
    2. Avirl Lavigne – especially in Mandarin
    3. Crank Dat Soulja Boy
    4. Alanis Morissette
    5. Rock puts on its boogie shoes

  24. ryke said

    !. Timbs owning the world, then writing a song about owning the world, then that song owning the world
    @. Soulja Boy
    #. Avril
    $. Mims
    %. Britney, bitch

  25. Katie said

    1 Rihanna
    2 Avril
    3 Soulja Boy
    4 T-Pain/Akon
    5 Britney

  26. Dan said

    1. Soulja Boy
    2. Akon + T=Pain
    3. Winehouse/Rehab
    4. Umbrella
    5. Avril Lavigne

  27. Millie said

    1. Rock Boogie Shoes
    2. Akon
    3. Britney
    4. Avril
    5. Soulja Boy

  28. Hilda said

    ubrella ella ella jeje,

  29. Erick said

    I guess the “Young Folks” Whistlegate probably didn’t have the meteoric impact on pop culture necessary to put it on this list… or was that very very late 2006?

    1 Throw some Ds and resulting puns (cheese, fees, Drew Brees)
    2 Britney
    4 Avril (delirious Mandarin version esp)
    5 Akon/T-Pain

  30. Jenni said

    If you desire to get a great deal from this article then you have to
    apply such strategies to your won blog.

Leave a Reply to mediocrityrules Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: